NAKED, SHORT & GREEDY:
Is Wall Street Abusing The
Practice Of Short-Selling Stocks?
Panel discussion presented by STP Advisory Services, LLC
October 19, 2006 in Los Angeles
The first event hosted by STP Advisory Services in Los Angeles presented a rare look into the damage done to investors and companies by short selling, stock lending and settlement failures. The event included remarks by three speakers with special insights.
Dr. Patrick Byrne, CEO of NASDAQ-traded Overstock.com, discussed the trading of “phantom shares” that appear to far outnumber those officially issued and outstanding in OSTK. Portfolio manager and financial writer Arne Alsin shared the insights he gained as a large-lot investor in markets systemically flawed by settlement failures. Dr. Susanne Trimbath, an economist with operations management experience at Depository Trust Company and the Pacific Clearing Corporation, illuminated how some practices could take advantage of loopholes in the settlement system to the detriment of both companies and investors.
Feedback from attendees indicates that the event was a resounding success. Even those already familiar with the subject admitted to gaining new insight.
After attendees mingled over breakfast, Moderator Wayne Jett opened the event. He introduced Patrick Byrne, CEO from Overstock.com. Patrick presented an animated slide show describing, in layman’s terms, how money can be transferred from individual investors without the reciprocal delivery of real stock shares. He was followed by Dr. Susanne Trimbath, CEO and Chief Economist of STP Advisory Services. Dr. Trimbath described how investors and companies can be damaged when short sales and stock lending are combined with trade settlement failures – the “Triumvirate of Trouble” – in the U.S. clearing and settlement system. The final speaker was Arne Alsin who received a rousing ovation for his stimulating, fresh perspective on the issues. Arne blamed the problems on the concentration of power in the broker-dealers and the lack of access to information for investors. He called for an even-handed, non-discriminatory enforcement of the rules plus greater disclosure of information to investors, especially information about settlement failures and stock lending in retail investors’ accounts.
After a short break, Wayne Jett moderated a discussion among the panelists followed by a Q&A session with the audience. The questions were so lively that virtually every attendee remained seated almost an hour after the advertised ending time of 11:00 am, while the session was extended. Questions ran the gamut from technical discussions of trading strategies and economic theories to strategies for financing entrepreneurial ventures in increasingly complex and dangerous capital markets.
Biographical information on the panelists, a complete schedule of the event activities and digital audio of the speakers’ presentations and discussions are available through the links below.
Acknowledgements: Wayne Jett and Jim Altenbach instigated the idea of having an event on this subject in Los Angeles and were instrumental in making it happen. Patrick Byrne and Arne Alsin adjusted their schedules several times to be available for appearance at this event. Sponsorship support was provided by Patrick Byrne. |